Commentary Cons. Phil. Book 2 Prosa 1
P. argues it is foolish to complain of adverse fortune, for B. should have known that fortune is always arbitrary and unjust.
- section 1
-
obticuit: < obticesco, "be struck dumb."
exorsa: < exordior, "begin."
- section 2
-
penitus: "deeply, thoroughly."
tantum animi tui: "so much of your soul" (but not all: cf. 1P6).
sicuti tu tibi fingis: to be taken closely with mutata; cf. sec. 9 of this prosa.
- section 3
-
illius prodigii: i.e., Fortuna.
fucos: literally, "dyes, rouges," here, "false appearances, deceptions."
eo usque: "up to this point" (a point specified by the dum [="until"] clause).
- section 4
-
si: si . . . reminiscare . . . cognosces . . . laborauerim: mixed future condition with subjunctive in protasis, indicative (future, then future perfect) in apodosis; cf. on 1P2.6.
reminiscare: si . . . reminiscare . . . cognosces . . . laborauerim: mixed future condition with subjunctive in protasis, indicative (future, then future perfect) in apodosis; cf. on 1P2.6.
cognosces: si . . . reminiscare . . . cognosces . . . laborauerim: mixed future condition with subjunctive in protasis, indicative (future, then future perfect) in apodosis; cf. on 1P2.6.
laborauerim: si . . . reminiscare . . . cognosces . . . laborauerim: mixed future condition with subjunctive in protasis, indicative (future, then future perfect) in apodosis; cf. on 1P2.6.
- section 5
-
Solebas: solebas . . . insectabare: the continuative force of the imperfect is strong in both verbs: "you used to . . . (regularly)."
praesentem: praesentem . . . blandientemque: sc. fortunam.
blandientemque: praesentem . . . blandientemque: sc. fortunam.
prolatis: prolatis . . . sententiis: ablative absolute, "rendering your judgment."
insectabare: solebas . . . insectabare: the continuative force of the imperfect is strong in both verbs: "you used to . . . (regularly)."
sententiis: prolatis . . . sententiis: ablative absolute, "rendering your judgment."
- section 6
-
contingit: "happens, occurs."
descisceres: "digress, deviate"; subjunctive in result clause.
- section 7
-
transmissum: "passed along"; modifies quod.
- section 8
-
rhetoricae suadela dulcedinis: rhetoric is what is employed in the prosae, music (cf. hac musica laris nostri uernacula) in the metra.
cumque hac: "and with this [i.e., rhetoric]"; the two main verbs of the sentence are the jussive subjunctives adsit and succinat. The construction would be clearer with a comma after deserit.
- section 10
-
sui: i.e., "of fortune" -- objective genitive, not possessive.
blandiebatur: blandiebatur . . . alluderet: this vacillation of verb mood has no effect on meaning.
alluderet: blandiebatur . . . alluderet: this vacillation of verb mood has no effect on meaning.
- section 11
-
innotuit: < innotesco, "become known."
- section 12
-
Si: Si . . . queraris: "If you approve (of her), use (i.e., take advantage of) her ways of behaving, don't complain."
utere: imperative.
ne queraris: subjunctive with ne in a prohibition. Si . . . queraris: "If you approve (of her), use (i.e., take advantage of) her ways of behaving, don't complain."
perniciosa ludentem: "[someone (i.e., Fortuna)] making a game of ruination."
esse: sc. causa.
debuisset: past potential subjunctive.
quam: sc. ea as antecedent.
non relicturam: sc. esse; indirect discourse governed by poterit esse securus (taken as verb of thinking/feeling).
- section 13
-
abituram: translate, "that is going to pass away."
manendi fida: literally, "faithful in remaining," here "that may be relied on to remain."
allatura: future active participle < adfero, "bring"; translate, "that is going to bring."
- section 14
-
ex arbitrio: "at (your) choice."
calamitosos: predicative, sc. homines.
fugax: "transient, fleeting"; though this word is in all the manuscripts, it may be an interpolation -- cf. Gruber.
- section 15
-
suffecerit: future perfect.
exitus: accusative plural.
prudentia: nominative; cf. imprudentia, 1P3.8.
in alterutro: i.e., in good fortune and in bad.
formidandas: formidandas . . . exoptandas: future passive participles (gerundives) of necessity: "that are to be feared . . . to be desired."
exoptandas: formidandas . . . exoptandas: future passive participles (gerundives) of necessity: "that are to be feared . . . to be desired."
- section 16
-
oportet: "it is necessary" + subjunctive.
intra fortunae aream: "on fortune's turf." Fortune is like a cruel and arbitrary empress presiding in the amphitheater.
- section 17
-
iniurius: "wrongful, unjust."
fueris: fueris . . . exacerbes: the variation between perfect and present subjunctive is without significance for the meaning.
exacerbes: fueris . . . exacerbes: the variation between perfect and present subjunctive is without significance for the meaning.
- section 18
-
quo: quo . . . quo: "whither."
quo: quo . . . quo: "whither."
promoueres: intransitive, "move forward."
inter se: here, "with each other."
- section 19
-
uoluentis rotae: From as early as the fifth century B.C. Fortune is depicted as the mistress of a wheel whose revolutions govern the fates of men; largely through Boethius the image impressed itself vividly on the Middle Ages. In the commonest form of illustration, four figures appear at the cardinal points of the wheel (cf. 2P2.9): at the top, a king wearing a crown (labeled: regno); at the right, a falling man, losing a crown (regnabam); at the bottom a figure prostrate with no crown (sine regno); and at the left, an ascending figure reaching for a crown (regnabo).
incipit: sc. Fortuna.
fors: predicative.
