Commentary Cons. Phil. Book 5 Prosa 1
B. insists that P. explain the nature of chance (i.e., casus); she denies that such a thing exists.
- section 1
-
tractanda: < tracto, "handle, treat."
expedienda: < expedio, "extricate, disentangle [from confusion]."
- section 2
-
dudum: dudum . . . dixisti: 4P6.2-4.
quaestionem: quaestionem . . . esse: accusative/infinitive in apposition with quod: "what you said, namely that . . ."
esse: quaestionem . . . esse: accusative/infinitive in apposition with quod: "what you said, namely that . . ."
dixisti: dudum . . . dixisti: 4P6.2-4.
re: here, "in reality."
- section 3
-
an: an . . . arbitrere: (= arbitreris) indirect question.
esse: esse . . . et quidnam esse casum: indirect statement: "[that] chance exists and what it is."
et quidnam esse casum: esse . . . et quidnam esse casum: indirect statement: "[that] chance exists and what it is."
arbitrere: an . . . arbitrere: (= arbitreris) indirect question.
- section 4
-
patriam: accusative of place to which.
- section 5
-
cognitu: ablative supine < cognosco.
auersa: probably adjective: "contrary, in the wrong direction," with preposition a.
ne: ne . . . possis: clause of fearing after uerendum est ("it is to be feared").
emetiendum: "traversing" (gerundive of purpose).
possis: ne . . . possis: clause of fearing after uerendum est ("it is to be feared").
- section 6
-
loco: here, "opportunity, facility"; a dative of purpose.
fuerit: future perfect.
ea: object of agnoscere ("to understand").
- section 7
-
omne: "every."
nihil: subject of ambigatur.
de sequentibus: "concerning the consequences [of your argument]."
ambigatur: potential subjunctive.
- section 8
-
Morem: Morem . . . geram: < morem gero, "oblige, humor," with dative.
geram: Morem . . . geram: < morem gero, "oblige, humor," with dative.
temerario: here, "accidental."
praeter subiectae rei significationem: "without signification of [any] subject"; i.e., casus is a word referring to no reality. Praeter regularly means "without" in later Latin.
Quis: quis . . . ullus: a pleonastic (redundant) later Latin combination; modifies locus. Translate: "what place . . . ?"
cohercente: cohercente . . . deo: ablative absolute.
deo: cohercente . . . deo: ablative absolute.
ullus: quis . . . ullus: a pleonastic (redundant) later Latin combination; modifies locus. Translate: "what place . . . ?"
- section 9
-
ueterum: e.g., Parmenides (cf. on 1P1.10).
refragatus est: < refragor, "oppose, thwart," with dative.
id: the principle nihil ex nihilo existere, taken up by hoc below.
illi: sc. ueteres.
de operante principio: "concerning the first mover," i.e., God.
materiali subiecto: "matter subject [to the first mover]."
omnium de natura rationum: "of all reasoning about nature."
- section 10
-
possibile est: governs the accusative/infinitive, casum . . . esse.
qualem: antecedent is huius modi in the previous line.
paulo ante: 5P1.8.
- section 11
-
iure: "by rights, justly."
lateat: "escape the notice of," here with accusative uulgus.
- section 12
-
Aristoteles: Aristoteles . . . in Physicis: Aristotle, Physics 2.4-5; more closely parallel is Metaphysics 1025a14ff.
in Physicis: Aristoteles . . . in Physicis: Aristotle, Physics 2.4-5; more closely parallel is Metaphysics 1025a14ff.
propinqua: with genitive.
- section 13
-
gratia: with genitive cuiuspiam rei.
aliudque: take closely with quam ("than") quod intendebatur.
obtingit: "happens, befalls."
ut si: introducing a hypothetical example.
defossi: < defodio, "dig up."
- section 14
-
fortuito: adverb, "by chance."
operatus: sc. esse.
- section 15
-
eo loci: "in that place"; loci is partitive genitive.
- section 16
-
compendii: "profit."
quod: sc. compendium.
obuiis sibi: "encountering each other."
gerentis: "of the one carrying out [the deed]."
- section 17
-
ut: introducing purpose clause after intendit.
quo: sc. loco.
hunc fodisse: accusative/infinitive with conuenit and concurrit.
- section 18
-
in his: "in these matters."
ob aliquid: "for some purpose."
- section 19
-
suis: "their own"; refers to cuncta.